Auburn & Lake Martin Real Estate Agent – Amy B. Cotney

Auburn’s #1 Real Estate Agent – Voted Best of 2025

Amy B. Cotney

REALTOR®

Selling a Great Home—Not a Mansion? You’re in the Right Place

Not every house has to be a million-dollar lakefront stunner. I work with homeowners like you—people who are ready for a new chapter, whether that means moving up, downsizing, or just making a change. If you’re thinking about selling, don’t hesitate to reach out.

Auburn’s #1 Real Estate Agent
Voted Best of 2025

Amy B. Cotney

REALTOR®

Featured Auburn & Lake Martin Homes

63 Flat Rock Lane

Lake Martin
Waterfront

$3,495,000

322 Lee Road 2218

5 BR, 3.5 Bath
5 Acres

$799,000

2456 Mimms Lane

Cottage Vibes
Primary Suite with Private Wing

$424,900

410 Geneva Street

Luxury and Convenience
Geneva Historic District

$399,900

466 Geneva Street

Craftsman Duet
Geneva Historic District

$399,900

416 Geneva Street

Modern Luxury
Geneva Historic District

$399,900

472 Geneva Street

Historic Character
Geneva Historic District

$399,900

2033 Armistead Lane

Cottage Charm
3 miles to Jordan Hare Stadium

$387,000

1661 S Camden Court

Completely Renovated
4 miles to Jordan-Hare Stadium

$450,000

310 E Samford Avenue #9

Walk to Downtown
Luxurious Condominium

$1,400,000

Making Real Estate Uniquely Personal

It’s not just about the deal—it’s about understanding your needs and guiding you every step of the way.

Featured Areas & Lifestyles

Auburn

Lake Martin

Condos

lee county

opelika

Luxury

Marianne Linton

Amy is so great to work with. She helped us find the perfect lake house two years ago and she just helped us sell our Auburn house. She is very knowledgeable and hard working and of course a blast to be around! The whole process was so easy and the house sold quickly. Hope I never have to move again but if I do I’ll ask Amy to help!

Merideth D.

Amy is an experienced realtor and has a vast knowledge of the Auburn/Opelika area and the surrounding communities! We became instant friends upon meeting. Her personality is one of her greatest qualities. Amy also has a huge network in the community and on all social media outlets, which can only help your visibility if you are a client.

Jordan Martin

Amy is the absolute best! When looking for our home in Auburn, we struck gold by teaming up with Amy. She was flawless in her communication, extremely patient and answered all our questions. She does so much work for you behind the scenes and made our home buying process a breeze. I cannot recommend Amy enough.

Amy Baker

I recently had the pleasure of working with Amy B. Cotney to purchase a new dream home in Auburn! From our initial conversations and throughout the whole process, Amy was professional, encouraging, honest, and resourceful. She is very knowledgeable about the local market and made sure I always felt like a priority. I highly recommend Amy B. Cotney to anyone looking for top-notch real estate services!!

Alexandra Maffett

Amy is an incredible realtor. We used her to sell our house in Auburn at the beginning of COVID. She was very responsive to all my questions. She even helped guide me in getting the house ready to sell, aka decluttering!!!! We were able to sell our house in just a few short days during a national pandemic. I truly believe that was because of all the awesome marketing Amy did. Thank you so much, Amy!!

Anne Marie Heston

Amy is the best realtor in Auburn. She was very patient in helping us find our first home. She showed us houses at all hours of the day and her honesty is unmatched. Highly recommend for all your Auburn home buying needs!

Amy B.

My husband and I were in town for the long holiday weekend and needed to get a lot of work done in a very short period of time! Amy was on it! She asked very in-depth questions before we even met in person and then had 9 properties all lined up ready for us to look at! We hit the ground running. I can’t wait to move into our next dream home! Hubby and I are still debating which one it will be…. Amy is the BEST!!

Elizabeth McKenzie

The best! Hands down Mrs. Amy is the absolute best realtor in town 🙂 She helped me SO much with buying my first home and I never would have been able to do it without her. Mrs. Amy is not just an amazing realtor she is also an amazing person! She is kind, joyful, and never meets a stranger. If you are looking to buy a home, visit Mrs. Amy and she will not lead you astray!

Holt Ingalls

Amazing realtor! If you want someone who is honest and cares for your best interest, she is the one for the job.

Turning Conversations Into Closings

In a world of automated emails and impersonal systems, I understand that homes are bought and sold through personal connections and meaningful conversations. I build strong relationships that lead to sold homes and happy buyers—through communication, not automation.